OPINION | This article contains commentary which reflects the author's opinion.


Senate Blocks Trump’s Nominee To The Federal Reserve Board

The path to the Federal Reserve for President Donald Trump’s controversial nominee Judy Shelton narrowed Tuesday after the Senate blocked a key procedural vote and a Republican senator who was one of her supporters said he came down with the coronavirus.

The Senate failed to advance Trump’s pick after Republicans Mitt Romney of Utah, Susan Collins of Maine joined the Senate’s Democrats in blocking Shelton’s appointment.

The 47-50 vote also came as Sens. Rick Scott, R-Fla., and Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, were absent from the chamber and unable to vote after being exposed to the coronavirus.

The Fed has aggressively eased monetary policy using measures Shelton previously called “extreme” to cushion the downturn caused by the coronavirus crisis and its economic fallout.

Trump’s Republican Party has a 53-47 majority in the current Senate, but so-called cloture vote was 47-50, with Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell voting “no” to preserve the option to reconsider Shelton’s nomination later.

The hope is for a re-do when Grassley and Scott return to the Senate floor.

A successful vote could require careful timing.

Republican Senator Lamar Alexander, who opposes Shelton’s nomination, is out of Washington this week but could cast a vote if one takes place when he is back.

Newly elected Democratic Senator Mark Kelly is eligible to take the oath of office as soon as Arizona certifies its election results, which is scheduled for Nov. 30. He expects to take office in early December.

Quarantines for COVID-19 typically last 14 days, meaning Grassley and Scott could be back at the Senate by then, health permitting.

Shelton, 66, has come under fire for inconsistent, controversial views, including an embrace of the gold standard and a shifting stance on interest rates as control of the White House passed from Democrat Barack Obama to Trump.

Shelton told lawmakers in her previous February confirmation hearing that “no one tells me what to do.”

Supporters praise an out-of-the-box thinker who they say can shake up an institution they view as being dominated by “groupthink” because of its consensus-driving decision-making style.

The vote on Shelton marks the first time since the establishment of modern Fed governance in 1935 that Congress has voted on a Fed nominee during a lame-duck session.

Beyond setting monetary policy, the Fed’s Board of Governors are responsible for a range of other tasks including decisions on bank supervision and, importantly at this junction, emergency lending programs like the ones the Fed has launched to help backstop and extend credit to coronavirus-hit businesses and local governments.

Shelton has argued the nation would be better off returning to the gold standard, and as recently as 2017 criticized the Fed’s power over money and financial markets as “quite unhealthy.”

During her Senate confirmation process, she called the Fed’s bond-buying and zero interest rates in the last crisis “extreme.”

Her views on rates have moved in lockstep with Trump’s. She lambasted easy money before his presidency but supported it after he took office, and has expressed skepticism over the Fed’s need to set policy independently from the president and Congress.

Her skepticism about the role of the Fed was part of the appeal for some Republicans voting “yes” on Tuesday.

“The Federal Reserve plays too much of a role shaping our economy,” Marco Rubio, a Republican senator from Florida, said in a statement after the vote. He added that he thinks Shelton shares his belief “that relying on the Federal Reserve to boost asset prices is no substitute for a strong American economy.”

Democrats voting against Shelton expressed concern over her lack of knowledge about the banking system. Shelton’s unfamiliarity with capital requirements and other protections against losses means it would be “imprudent” to appoint her to the Federal Reserve Board, Massachusetts Senator Elizabeth Warren said on Twitter on Tuesday afternoon, “especially during this crisis.”

Other Trump picks for the central bank have faltered earlier in the process, including former Republican presidential candidate Herman Cain and economic adviser Stephen Moore.

Whether Shelton is ultimately confirmed or not, Trump will have put his mark on the Fed. He has nominated all but one of its board’s current five members.

The White House expressed confidence Shelton would be confirmed eventually, with spokesman Judd Deere tweeting she is “incredibly qualified,” and adding, “The @WhiteHouse fully supports her.”

Published With Permission From Reuters